N
The Daily Insight

Should I help Captain Monroe?

Author

Ava Robinson

Updated on February 28, 2026

As the player in charge of Arthur's actions, you can refuse to assist Monroe at all. Captain Monroe clearly has a heart, and if you don't help him, you're proving Arthur Morgan doesn't.

Likewise, people ask, what happens if you dont help Captain Monroe?

Arthur Morgan first meets Captain Monroe when he tries assisting Rains Fall and his people. While at the Native Americans' camp, Monroe asks Arthur to help him with a matter he's dealing with. Captain Monroe clearly has a heart, and if you don't help him, you're proving Arthur Morgan doesn't.

Also, how do you help Captain Monroe in rdr2? Captain Monroe needs your help to steal some vaccine that the army had diverted away from the reservation. Meet with him in the reservation and skip the cinematic. Follow Monroe on horseback and he will lead you to a good place to ambush the convoy that is carrying the vaccine.

Similarly, it is asked, what happens if you help Captain Monroe?

During your ride with Rains Fall and Captain Monroe, the latter will ask you whether you would be willing to help him assist the tribe. Choosing to help him will help you earn some honor, and unlock another mission later on in the story.

What happens if you don't help Mary rdr2?

Declining to help Mary will prevent players from being able accept a future mission to help Mary's father. If Red Dead Redemption 2 players want to avoid this mistake, they should agree to help Mary. If players choose to decline helping Mary, the quest will end here, with Mary and Arthur sharing their farewells.

Related Question Answers

Do you surrender with Dutch RDR2?

Eventually Dutch will tell you to make a break for it - there's too many. You get to a dead end with a broken bridge. Dutch says to follow his lead, however, you need to surrender or else you'll both get shot. Press the button when it prompts you to.

What happened captain Monroe?

An honest and loyal military officer who graduated from West Point, Captain Monroe was sent down from Washington following reports of unrest in the region. Despite his best efforts to help the reservation and make peace between the Wapiti and the US Army, the conflict continued to escalate.

What happens to rains fall RDR2?

Rains Fall reveals that he and his tribe were forced to flee to Canada and that he had temporarily returned to America to mourn the death of Eagle Flies, which he had still not fully recovered from. After John gives his condolences on the loss of his son, Rains Fall then boards a train to return to Canada.

How did Arthur get tuberculosis?

Due to Arthur beating up Thomas Downes, who has Tuberculosis, under Leopold Strauss' orders, while Arthur held him up against the fence, Downes coughs on him, which causes him to receive Tuberculosis.

How do I get absolution not seek?

The "Do Not Seek Absolution" questline can be begun in Chapter 6 as well; during Chapter 6, Arthur gets an extra 50% honor for every honorable action he does. Waiting to take advantage of this stat boost will make it easier to get Arthur's honor level up—if it's not already there—and will then open up the quest.

What tribe is rains fall from?

Rains Fall is the chief of the Wapiti, a Native American clan who once called the plains of New Hanover their home. Like many real-life tribes at the time, Rains Fall and the Wapiti are forced to live on a reservation.

Did Arthur have a son RDR2?

Arthur had a son, Isaac, with a waitress named Eliza; he demonstrated regular support for them until they were killed by robbers. Over time, Arthur transformed into Dutch's most dedicated enforcer.

Are eagle flies dead?

Does Eagle Flies Die? Eagle Flies is a young Native warrior who gets caught up in the Van der Linde gang and the U.S. Army. Arthur and Charles try to save him, but ultimately he dies from mortal wounds.

What chapter is goodbye dear friend RDR2?

Goodbye, Dear Friend is the 77th main story mission in Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2). This walkthrough will guide you through all objectives of Goodbye, Dear Friend Main Quest including all Gold Medals for 100% completion. Goodbye, Dear Friend is unlocked after completing A Rage Unleashed.

How do you replay missions in rdr2?

In RDR 2 you can replay the main story missions as many times as you like. Pause the game, go to the Progress option and then select Story. Go to the desired chapter and select the mission you want to replay.

How do you subdue all soldiers on a boat in rdr2?

You must knock out 2 soldiers on the boat - these two are your easiest. So equip your fists, sneak up behind the first guard, and press circle/b to perform a stealth knockout.

How do you go back to the last checkpoint in Red Dead Redemption?

Yes, press left on the D-Pad to go to Log, press on the mission button, hold Square or X to abandon the mission and you'll be given the option to restart the checkpoint, the mission, or to abandon it.

How do you jump off a horse in rdr2?

Horse Controls (PS4)
  1. Left Analog Stick - Steer.
  2. X - Tap to change speed; hold to match speed to companion; double tap to move up in formation.
  3. L3 - Calm horse.
  4. Square - Tap to jump, climb, or vault over obstacles; hold to pick up or search objects; while hunting, hold to draw animal attention.

How many chapters are in Red Dead Redemption 2?

There are six chapters in the main story of Red Dead Redemption 2, but that isn't the end of the game. There are two additional epilogue chapters at the end, bringing a total of eight chapters in the full Red Dead 2 campaign.

How do you steal medicine in rdr2?

To retrieve the medicine from the supply wagon in Honor, Amongst Thieves for Captain Monroe in Red Dead Redemption 2 ride your horse up to the side of the supply wagon being careful to stay behind the soldiers. Jump over to the wagon and search the medicine crate.

How do you get the owl trinket in rdr2?

A player can only collect this trinket by completing the optional mission Archeology for Beginners. If the player completes the mission and retrieves Rains Fall's artifacts without killing any of the soldiers at the camp, then Rains Fall will give the trinket to Arthur as a reward.

When can you meet Hamish rdr2?

The player is able to visit Hamish after one in-game day passes. He can then be found at Veteran's Homestead.

How do you jump from horse to wagon in rdr2 PC?

Use Square or X to jump. Once you landed quietly in the wagon, steal the supplies by pressing Triangle or Y. Jump off the wagon by pressing Square or X, your horse will follow.

How do you get on the wagon in rdr2?

Wagons in Red Dead Redemption are found randomly in all three territories, driven by a pair of NPCs. The player can take over a wagon by either killing the NPCs or coming up to the side of the wagon and pulling the driver off of the wagon.

Should I help Mary save her dad rdr2?

What's important to note here is that this choice might lock you out of another mission. If you choose to help Maryie, later on, she'll ask you to save her father, too. So, you should know that before you just give her the cold shoulder. In this game, accepting to help people is always the better choice.

What happens if you spare Cleet?

Cleet eventually tells the trio that Micah is hiding out at Mount Hagen and tries to convince them that he is "one of the good guys". John can choose to either hang him or spare him, although sparing Cleet will simply result in him being shot dead by Sadie instead.

Who did Abigail Marston sleep with?

An orphan, Abigail eventually became part of the Van der Linde gang after being introduced to them all by Uncle in 1894. As a prostitute, she slept with most of the members of the gang, but ultimately fell in love with John and fell pregnant with their son, Jack, when she was only eighteen.

What happens if you say no to Sadie?

If you say no to Sadie she will ride off alone. She will still agree to help John and his family escape.

When should I make a move on Mary Linton?

Mary asked Arthur if he has some other things to do because he wants to offer Arthur to watch with her in the Theater. When you accept the offer of Mary, Arthur has a chance to make a move to Mary Linton. After the first show, there will be a menu selection when you focus to Mary. The Make a Move menu.

Can Arthur sleep with anyone rdr2?

Much like the original Red Dead Redemption, sex and nudity are not featured in Red Dead Redemption 2. There is a pseudo-romantic series of missions that focus on a past lover, but no sex scenes or romantic relationships appear as optional activities in the game.

Can Arthur get with Mary?

Arthur met Mary at a young age whilst he rode with the Van der Linde gang. Arthur admits that he reciprocates her feelings but declines, stating that they need money, that there's still people in the gang he needs to protect, and that he doesn't want her to get hurt. The two part ways again for the final time.

Is Jack Arthur's son?

For much of Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur Morgan acts as a father figure to John and Abigail Marston's son Jack. Playing as Morgan, gamers have to take the boy on a series of bonding activities, including horseback riding and going fishing.